Friday, November 20, 2026
World

Sunrise on the Reaping Reviews: One Star From The Guardian, ‘Best Since Catching Fire’ From Others — Panem Returns Deeply Divided

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens worldwide today, Friday, November 20 — and it arrives as the most argued-over blockbuster of the year. The review embargo lifted on November 17, and the verdicts do not merely differ; they describe two different films. The film sits at roughly 70 to 75 per cent on Rotten Tomatoes depending on the hour, with a 56 on Metacritic and 7.4 on IMDb — respectable numbers that hide a genuine critical split.

The praise is emphatic. IGN calls it one of the best instalments in the franchise, nearly matching Catching Fire’s emotional heights. RogerEbert.com awards 3.5 out of 4 and calls it a film for the fans who grew up with these stories. The Hollywood Reporter’s David Rooney writes that Joseph Zada invests the young Haymitch Abernathy with “tenacity, kindness and heartrending vulnerability”, judging his origin story far more involving than Coriolanus Snow’s in the first prequel. The pans are just as loud. The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw gives one star out of five, writing that the film has no authentic reason to exist beyond extracting money from its fanbase. The New York Times calls it “both bloated and limited”, and IndieWire grades it a C-minus “dreary slog”, with several critics citing the 158-minute runtime and a heavy lean on nostalgia. Empire splits the difference at three stars.

The split matters because of the money riding on it. As our tracking report detailed, presales are Lionsgate’s best since the pandemic and forecasts run from $80 million to $140 million for the North American opening: https://filmverse.in/hunger-games-sunrise-on-the-reaping-box-office-tracking-80-million-presales-wicked-november-20/ A Filmverse comparison puts the divide in franchise context: at ~70 per cent, Sunrise sits level with both Mockingjay films, above The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes (64 per cent) and well below Catching Fire (90 per cent) — historically, that band has still produced $100 million-plus openings when the fanbase shows up on day one.

Here is the Filmverse take: divided reviews rarely hurt a franchise film on opening weekend — they hurt it on the second weekend, when casual viewers replace the faithful. Sunrise on the Reaping has already won its first battle in presales. Whether it becomes a resurrection or a one-weekend event now depends on the audience score, not the critics. Watch that number, not the Tomatometer.

Watch the official trailer below:

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is now playing in cinemas, including in India in English.

Source: Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, IGN, The Guardian, The Hollywood Reporter, IndieWire and RogerEbert.com. Box-office figures are trade estimates.

Team Filmverse

Filmverse is an independent entertainment news desk covering Bollywood and Indian cinema — news, trailers, reviews and box office, published daily from Mumbai.

Team Filmverse

Filmverse is an independent entertainment news desk covering Bollywood and Indian cinema — news, trailers, reviews and box office, published daily from Mumbai.

Leave a Reply